WARNING SPOILERS
When this film starts, it is lovely how they show the people in
heaven cleaning the stars, it is a nice touch and beginning.
After the opening credits, and after Billy Bigelow (Gordon MacRae)
and Julie Jordan (Shirley Jones) meet at the Carousel, the script is a bit weak
However, it works for the film. The part where Julie’s friend Carrie Pipperidge
(Barbara Ruick) is crying is poorly acted and unnecessary.
The film is dated and the part where Carrie sings about being a ‘meek
wife’ hasn’t stood the test of time. Mostly the songs work well during the
film.
Some of the film is still relevant today, the part where Billy a
bit of a rogue says “You’re a funny kid” to Julie when she stays with him on
the path. This proves the theory that there is someone out there for everyone.
This is nice to see and during this scene they sing one of the classic songs in
the film ‘If I Loved You’
The film is a mix of a musical ghost story, love story and a fairy
tale, as Billy and Julie, although they have only just recently met, they
quickly get married.
During the song ‘June is bursting out all over’, the dancing is
well choreographed and performed to a high standard.
I don’t know why they had to put in, that Billy hit Julie, if this
is just to prove he is a rogue, we already know and don’t need to be shown
again. It is a waste of film time putting that part in.
Another dated part and where the script could be better is when
Carrie keeps referring to her future husband as ‘Mr. Snow’ (Robert
Rounseville). Why not have her call him by his first name Enoch, this would
sound less formal.
Another part where you think the film is going to take one route,
only for Billy to have a change of heart. Some people are just not cut out for
marriage, that is until he finds out he is going to be a Dad, to a son, and
just when we think ‘does he not know girls exist’ he has a realisation that the
baby might be a girl, and he starts singing in an accepting nature about being
a Dad to a daughter, which is heart-warming to hear.
A lesson to be learnt that has stood the test of time, is that a
Father is a ‘Role-Model’ to their daughter, and he wants her to ‘Want for
nothing’ and only to associate with the best people and not the ‘Bums’ he, her
dad hung out with.
Although this film is a flashback into Billy’s life on earth, it
is over an hour before he is killed and goes up to heaven. The film could be
shorter and still work. Another classic song featured in the film ‘You’ll Never
Walk Alone’ is well placed after Billy dies.
Despite the name of the film a Carousel is only featured at the
beginning of the film and a nod to one nearer the end. This part is cleverly
done where, as part of a dance routine the men are carrying the women around,
walking in a circle, and the women are forming a shape in the men’s arms,
creating a human carousel. Carousel being the name of the film I did think one
would feature more often, or they could have thought of a different name for
the film.
Billy is at last sent back to help his 15-year-old daughter Louise
(Susan Luckey), she is hanging out with the undesirables her father didn’t want
her to. Can Billy help her? Getting her to believe in the words of the song
‘You’ll Never Walk Alone’ is a start.
The ending to this film is a bit flimsy and short. This film can
be condensed down and you could still have the same storyline and more of Billy
coming back the earth to see his daughter.
Overall a film worth watching, with some catchy songs and bright
dance routines.